O Boswell from
Smithtown, NY on Mar 8, 2014
As the name indicates, these people make pies. I love a fresh pie, and before I found this place I didn't know anywhere locally that I could get them. No, the pies at the grocery store do not count. Those pies are way too sweet. These are perfect.
Alfred R from
Saint James, NY on Jun 10, 2013
Want to get someone a really special dessert for a special occasion? Hire Sweet as Pie! They will custom make you a cake for any occasion, and they are very creative people. The cake I ordered my daughter not only looked fantastic, but it tasted every bit as delicious as it looked. She was thrilled when we presented it to her on her 10th birthday. I know we will be back to get her another surprise cake for her 11th next year! And if we can come up with an excuse to commission something in the meantime, we will most definitely be doing that. Thank you for the amazing cake!
Sara H from
Saint James, NY on Mar 25, 2013
Last year I ordered a special custom cake from Sweet as Pie for my daughter's Sweet 16 birthday party, and it was so cute and delicious! This year I was going to get her another one, but for some reason they aren't doing cakes right now. They're still doing cupcakes though, so I ordered her birthday cupcakes instead. I thought she'd be disappointed at first, but they were so tasty, and she told me she was just glad I'd ordered from Sweet as Pie again instead of getting her a cake from somewhere else. Next year hopefully I can get her another cake. My birthday is in a couple of months, so maybe I'll treat myself with a cake if they start offering them again!
Share Your Review
