Long Island Yellow Pages .com
Find: Near:   

Yellow Pages » Restaurants » Shirley Yellow Pages » Freshy Fresh Bagels

917 Montauk Hwy
Shirley, NY 11967
Get Directions

Tel: (631) 281-2243

Appears In:

HyperLocal (NEW):
Shirley Restaurants

Listing Stats
1,482 Splash Page Views
2,138 Summary Views


Rate This Company:
Thank you for your feedback! Your business rating has been saved.

More about us: the real' old fashioned boiled & baked bagel, large variety of bagels baked fresh daily, we also carry a wide variety of freshly baked bakery items, let us make you one of our delicious sandwiches, homemade cream cheese spreads & salads made fresh daily and we are always here to cater to your needs.

Hours: For hours, call (631) 281-2243

Nearby Businesses - Map View

Report incorrect info


Post Review

 Freshy Fresh Bagels Reviews   
5 out of 5 stars Todd E. Richmond from Mastic Beach, NY on Jun 11, 2014
I am really impressed with this little place. You don't expect all that much out of a bagel restaurant, but they are fast, the bagels are *always* fresh, and the sandwiches are mouthwatering amazing. I also can't praise their service enough! They are friendly and greet you right away even when they have a line. You never feel forgotten or neglected.
5 out of 5 stars Harold from Upton, NY on Dec 14, 2013
For this area, my expectations are usually low. I was surprised by how nice this restaurant is. It seems like it belongs in a classier neighborhood. The staff are extremely nice, and the bagels are delicious. My only complaint is that they could be a bit bigger, not that the price point isn’t entirely reasonable. Also … amazing—if you show up after 3 pm, you can get a dozen bagels for like $4. Fresh made bagels! They have some amazingly cool flavors too. Love the spinach one.
5 out of 5 stars Erik A. from Mastic Beach, NY on Sep 6, 2013
It's just another bagel place I suppose, but what can I say? I can't get enough bagels, and I like them better than the last place I used to patron before I moved by a long shot. They are always warm and fresh, and they have so many kinds you can order!
5 out of 5 stars AR from Manorville, NY on Dec 21, 2012
Bagels! One of life's simplest pleasures, and one that never gets old. It's always the really simple, classic foods that stick for me. As much as I love gourmet cooking, I'm happiest with a bagel and cream cheese or something else just as simple. And boy do they have cream cheese here--every flavor you can imagine. I just love it!
5 out of 5 stars OL from Mastic Beach, NY on Nov 21, 2012
Every time I move to a new area, one of my first moves is to look for a bagel place! Freshy Fresh Bagels lives up to its name. The bagels which I get here are always warm and fresh fro the oven. This is especially the case on busy days. The line is a drawback, but the fact is, all those crowds force them to push through more bagels, so that guarantees you'll get something hot out of the oven.

Perfect for stocking up bagels for the week, and also great for a quick sandwich before I head to the office.
Share Your Review

Do you have any experience using Freshy Fresh Bagels? If so, please rate your experience and let others hear about it using the form below.
Your Name:
City, State:
My Rating:

My Review:
Do not enter html
Please enter this code into the box below.
Enter Code:
Advertisers - Contact Your Long Island Yellow Pages Sales Representative to make changes to your listing.