EV from
Stony Brook, NY on Mar 20, 2014
There's no way that I could ever say anything bad about Eleni's. I have been going here for over a year now, and I have been nothing but impressed. I love their pizza, and they are also incredibly helpful and friendly. It really feels like a nice family restaurant, and it's pleasant to eat in--which I can't usually say about pizza restaurants. I used to only ever get takeout at my old place, but here I sit down for a meal regularly.
I Parrish from
Selden, NY on Sep 30, 2013
If you come in here, plan ahead for the crowds--or order takeout and skip the wait. That's usually the best option. It's not always crowded, but let's say ... maybe 3 times out of 4, when i come in, it's packed. They have amazing deals on certain nights, and people here take advantage of them. You should too--just take my advice about ordering ahead!
Gary E. Moore from
Ronkonkoma, NY on Jul 1, 2013
My old pizza place closed a couple months back. I tried two other pizza restaurants before I went to Eleni's and finally found something that was as good as the closed restaurant. I am glad to find quality at a good price and really good service too. I may even like Eleni's better than the old place.
Jenny E from
Selden, NY on Jul 1, 2013
Good pizza and pasta at stellar prices. The only problem is that it can be ridiculously crowded in here, which can make the service slow to nonexistent on certain nights (usually the nights when they have specials). My recommendation is to come in and get takeout instead of eating in, unless you show up and nobody's there (not too likely to happen). Plus, you don't want to skip out on the special nights just because they're packed. Better to just take your food home with you and enjoy it.
Share Your Review
Report incorrect info
